Why Don’t Lawyers Do What You Ask Them To Do?

Share Post:

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email


In his third and final guest blog, leading legal sector consultant Simon McCrum looks at why policies and procedures are not followed.


Having been team leader, department head, division head, and Managing Partner, I understand well the frustration (and anger) that Managing Partners and CEO’s voice to me. “We’ve asked them a dozen times, but still they aren’t doing what we need!” is the way the conversation usually goes.

What is it that they’re not doing?

There’s a long list:

  • Not recording all the time they spend on client files
  • Not sending out the retainer letter at the outset
  • Not defining the retainer in sufficient detail
  • Not getting money on account
  • Not closing files
  • Not getting client ID
  • Not ascertaining precisely who or what the client is
  • Not recording all requisite info on the system or on the file
  • Not identifying the source of the work (for the Marketing team)
  • Not chasing their own bills
  • Not doing transfers to pay bills or to pay disbursements

The list goes on, and it builds up to a scenario in our profession where in very many firms, highly-paid and very clever lawyers don’t do what the business needs them to do.

Why aren’t policies and procedures followed? I believe the start of the answer is that very often chief amongst the culprits are the partners themselves. If they don’t follow the rules, then they’re not rules, are they?

What sanctions are there for not adhering to the rules?

None, usually. Someone who does good billing, for example, can be excused a dozen behavioural shortcomings, and very often a lawyer’s reward and progress up the firm is based solely on their billing. So, what will everyone focus on at the expense of everything else?

There is no “silver bullet” that can change things overnight. But there are ways that you can reduce this recalcitrance, including the following steps:

  1. Make it an absolute rule for the partners to adhere to policies – if they don’t, the whole thing is shot. Such are the benefits for the business of getting everyone adhering to your policies, that you can and should take a hard line here in bringing in a non-negotiable approach from the top tier in the firm.
  2. The things you are asking everyone to do are ultimately for the benefit of the whole – in a team culture the whole team has to play to the rules, and un-team-like behaviours ought to be addressed.
  3. Make adherence to detailed policies and practises part of your appraisal, reward, and promotion criteria. This is the “carrot” part. If some people are doing things right and others are doing things wrong but getting away with it, it undermines any team culture you are trying to develop – let everyone know that to get in and to stay in your team, you have to adhere to team rules.
  4. Ultimately, you should have a “stick” part too. Bad behaviours damage the business. They drive your Business Support teams round the bend and detract them from the positive things they could be doing for your business. Given a fair chance to understand the policies and why they’re there, someone who continues to disregard them – whatever their level in the firm – means that you will forever be driving with a handbrake on.

In short, everyone’s got a boss – and the boss is the business and its needs.

Simon McCrum , founder of McCrum & Co, a management consultancy for law firms, helps law firms strengthen what he calls the “Foundations for their Future” and then use those foundations as a platform for real growth.

Are you ready to transform the way you use data?

Our Business Intelligence software for law firms integrates seamlessly into your firm, with first-class training, support and assistance on hand every step of the way.
– Guide –

Top 25 KPIs that law firms don’t measure (but should)

Are you looking to improve performance in your law firm? In this handy guide you will find answers to:

– Webinar –

How top law firms use data to improve performance

Frustrated by a lack of real-time reporting in your firm?
Need your fee earners to up their game commercially?
Fed up with paying your accountant to “format reports”?

More Updates

Katchr is 10

This month Katchr is 10! Yes 10 years since Niall and I stepped out from our previous employer to see if we could do any

Top 25 KPIs that law firms don’t measure (but should)

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive regular updates and law firm management tips from Katchr and to get instant access to this free resource.

Please note that by submitting this form, you agree to receive marketing messages and other communications from Katchr. You may opt-out of receiving further communications at any time. For more information click to see our privacy policy.